Predatory Publishing

Dubious journals and bogus conferences threaten scientific integrity. Here, we explain how to identify them and take specific steps to protect your work.

Foto: Ein Bücherregal in einer Bibliothek mit verschiedenen Büchern. Ein Buch trägt den Titel 'Ganzheitliche Gestaltung von Investmentprozessen'.

What are predatory journals or conferences?

The term “predatory journals” refers to a fraudulent business model employed by certain open-access publishers. They give the impression that they publish legitimate academic journals and charge exorbitant fees for this service.

Contrary to what one might expect, however, there is neither a quality assurance process nor editorial review, as is customary with reputable journals.

As a result, predatory journals do not adhere to academic and ethical standards for the publication of scientific works. This is also evident in the absence of a proper peer-review process and correct citation practices.

Furthermore, content from predatory journals is often not indexed in relevant academic databases, meaning that the works are not accessible to the academic community.

In addition to predatory journals, so-called predatory conferences are becoming increasingly common: companies organize sham conferences in which moderators and participants are outright exploited. These sham conferences offer no scientific value but serve solely to maximize profits for the organizing companies.

How can you recognize them?

Below, we would like to provide you with some guidelines for identifying dubious journals and conferences:

Be wary of publishers without verifiable contact information and emails that resemble spam. Another red flag may be a very short turnaround time from submission to publication—typically within just a few days. Information regarding author fees and a peer-review process is also often missing. You should also be skeptical if a journal is not well-known within your academic community.

Review portals and checklists, such as Think.Check.Submit., can also help you make an informed decision about choosing a specific journal as a publication medium. An overview such as Beall’s List can be helpful in identifying known predatory journals.

To get an overview of predatory conferences, you can consult the Think.Check.Attend. checklist.

Please note, however, that such lists cannot be considered exhaustive.

As a starting point for further research on this topic, feel free to refer to this LinkedIn post by our former faculty member, Prof. Dr. Rüdiger Hahn.

What can you do?

Always critically evaluate open-access journals and conferences using the criteria listed above before submitting your work.

In addition, you should avoid citing predatory journals and conferences in your work. By doing so, you protect yourself and your work, and you also help prevent these from spreading further.

Contact

If you have any questions or would like more information, please contact us at: wiso_forschung(at)uni-hohenheim.de